
There are few people arguing with Alan Milburn’s analysis that youth unemployment is too high and too little is done to help young people into work or training.
There are nearly one million 18-24 year olds not in education, employment or training (Neet) in the UK, the highest figure since 2014 and the highest rate across Europe bar Romania.
Milburn’s ambitious report, From a Welfare State to a Working State, proposes extensive new support to help people into work, and training and work experience opportunities to “end long-term youth unemployment once and for all”. But it also proposes severe welfare cuts for under-25s with health issues, over which arguments have already begun.
What is Milburn proposing?
Former health minister Milburn, commissioned by Keir Starmer in November last year, insists he is not calling the 13.5 per cent of Neet 16-24 year olds “work-shy”. In his lengthy report, he calls for large-scale investment to get that figure down to 6.8 per cent.
Milburn has picked up on Burnham’s ambition to “rewire the state” and has drawn the NHS, the education sector, devolved authorities and immigration policy into his scope, as well as employment services and welfare. He believes countries with persistently low Neet rates such as Norway share this “whole system approach”.
“The best reform option is one that has never been tried before – the creation of a new and different system for young people from the one that serves older adults,” states the report.
At its core are three guarantees for young people: a statutory entitlement to a route into education, training or work; health, employment, functional and practical help to take up those opportunities; and a locally-led Youth Opportunity Service (YOS) charged with delivering both guarantees.
Praising the Milburn report in the Commons, work and pensions secretary Pat McFadden said the “first call” in funding the necessary investment would be cuts, or “ reprioritisation” as he called it, in all departmental spending.
The opportunity guarantee is for government-subsidised jobs, with employers receiving £3,000 for each young person they recruit, further and higher education places, apprenticeships, work placements, volunteering and even help into self-employment.
The report says young people who are already Neet should be guaranteed access to services such as vocational rehabilitation, talking therapies and counselling within three months, providing they have a participation plan agreed with the YOS. It calls for a requirement on health authorities to “sufficiently fund and commission” health-related services needed by their local YOS.
Milburn says that if the guarantees are backed by £5.8 billion of investment, they could bring 440,000 people into sustained work by 2036.
“The response to the Interim Report has convinced me that there is a visceral mood for change in the country,” he writes. “Families feel it. Employers feel it. Politicians feel it too. They all know that the risk of a lost generation of young people is real, and more importantly they want to do something about it.”
For Milburn, doing something also entails sharply cutting the benefits of young Neet people who claim personal independence payment (PIP) and the health element of Universal Credit (UC). Milburn describes many of these people – new claimants with conditions such as anxiety, depression, ADHD and autism – as beneficiaries, because they are trapped on benefits, when under the new system they would be expected to work.
They will lose PIP and the health UC payment. PIP claimants whose disability-related extra costs are “well established, significant, and ongoing” may be eligible for a new additional cost allowance in specific cases. There will also be a new local health and disability fund and a severe and complex needs insurance fund for targeted support.
Together, Milburn says, these “beneficiaries” will contribute to welfare cuts beginning in 2029/30, continuing so that by 2036/37 they will cumulatively reach £13.7 billion. By that year annual welfare savings will be £3.6 billion. However, he insisted existing financial help for claimants should not be reduced before the replacement support and opportunity are in place.
Milburn did not shy away from addressing the supposed needs of employers and their ability to hire young people. He advocates lower payroll taxes, including a cut in employer National Insurance – raised by former Chancellor Rachel Reeves –beginning with the retail and hospitality sectors, in which many young people get their first jobs.
He also urged caution over the government’s aim of aligning the minimum wage wage for 18-20 year olds with the adult rate. “If the cost to the employer is almost identical, too often the young person will lose out.”
How did Milburn’s report land?
At 278 pages, with a thud, offering those on the right and the left much to digest. Charities and campaigners agreed with Milburn’s emphasis on support but opposed the proposed cuts – in their own right and because they imply that young people somehow enjoy a lower cost of living than the over-25s.
Those on the right welcomed Milburn’s cuts as their own policies but said he did not sufficiently incentivise employers to hire.
The Joseph Rowntree Foundation (JRF), which campaigns against poverty, said Milburn was right to outline an ambitious plan but that disability cuts would risk undermining the change it seeks to achieve.
Recognising the scale of failing those in Neet is a “watershed moment”, said Katie Schmuecker, principal policy officer at JRF. “But cutting sick and disabled young people’s benefits should not be part of this package. Financial support is part of what helps young people take up earning or learning. The wider support offer won’t succeed if the young people it is meant to help are also struggling to afford food or the bus to college.”
The New Economics Foundation (NEF) called for a demand-side approach to the youth employment crisis, creating new jobs through local economic planning and industrial strategy.
“There is little evidence that health benefits are too generous or that they are driving young people out of work, while cutting them is likely to push people into poverty and make it harder for them to find work,” said George Bangham, head of social policy at NEF.
“Cuts to benefits also don’t solve the fundamental problem that there aren’t enough opportunities for young people. Recent NEF research found that in Blackpool there are only five online vacancies for every 100 people out of work and on Universal Credit.”
Some of the Labour MPs who opposed Starmer’s welfare cuts, such as Meg Hillier, seem to be on board with Milburn – but that may not persist as the government decides which of his reforms to implement, and when.
Labour MPs who have already opposed the proposed cuts include John McDonnell, who asked why we are not taxing wealth instead, Clive Lewis and Brian Leishman, who said disability cuts are “not compassionate and not what a Labour government should do”.
What people are saying
“Instead of asking a young person to prove what they cannot do, the system should begin by asking what they need to build a future.” - Work and pensions secretary Pat McFadden
“What it is is yet more kicking things into the long grass. We don’t have 10 years. We need to get jobs now.” - Kemi Badenoch, leader of the opposition
“Our plan would shut off the Neets pipeline at source, with 100 hours of real work experience before 18 and a careers coach for every young person.” - Ed Davey, Liberal Democrat leader
“Gordon Brown put a windfall tax on privatised utilities to pay for Labour’s new deal to help people into work. Andy Burnham’s looking like he intends to do it off the back of young disabled people.” - Green Party leader Zack Polanski
“I agree with the general drift of the Milburn report, but it’s too little and too slow.” - Nigel Farage, leader of Reform UK
What happens next
Ministers will consider the Milburn report – and the complicating factor of next week’s Timms Review into PIP – ahead of a white paper on welfare reform next year. But as much of the Milburn report strays outside welfare, that will not be enough legislation to achieve its radical aims.
Milburn and Burnham agree that cuts won’t happen before support is in place, but also that welfare savings will start to flow by 2029. For both to be true means the extra support must be rapidly put in place.
Further into the future, Milburn acknowledges there might be an anomaly in treating young people differently from older ones. His long-term solution? “The Government should act with urgency to bring forward new proposals for a reformed welfare system for over-25 year-olds.”
About the author: Kevin Gopal is a Manchester-based journalist who has returned to freelancing after editing Big Issue North from 2007 until its closure in 2023. He writes regularly for The Lead to untangle the issues facing the UK and also reporting on social justice and other issues across the North of England as part of our award-winning The Lead Local titles.
About The Lead Untangles: In an era where misinformation is actively and deliberately used by elected politicians and where advocates and opposers of beliefs state their point of view as fact, sometimes the most useful tool reporters have is to help readers make sense of the world. If there is something you’d like us to untangle, email ed@thelead.uk and you can see every edition of The Lead Untangles so far.
👫Found this edition of The Lead Untangles useful? Share this story with your friends, family and colleagues to help us reach more people with our independent journalism, always with a focus on people, policy and place.
We’ll be back in your inbox on Saturday with the next part of our series digging deep into the misinformation and disinformation that is rife online and offline across the UK. Make sure you’re subscribed to get it first.



