This is how we fix Universal Credit
The basic rate of benefit support falls woefully short – Iain Porter, senior policy advisor at the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, explains what needs to happen now.
This week, MPs debated the annual benefits ‘Uprating Order’ on how much benefits will rise by this year. But without an evidence-based foundation, this annual process always proves arbitrary and unfit for purpose, as the updated Universal Credit rates never reflect the real cost of essentials.
Instead, we need an independent process that draws on research, including from people with direct experience of living on a low income, to advise politicians on how much the minimum amount of Universal Credit needs to be to afford essentials.
Being unable to afford essentials like food, heating or toiletries is a grinding experience.
Desperate families tell of the relentless struggle to make ends meet; how precarious life feels as they focus on just surviving; about “impossible trade-offs, not genuine choices”; and how they “can only take so much”. Poverty also damages people’s health, relationships, opportunities and children’s education, with a knock-on effect that can last years.
Underlying deepening poverty, rising destitution and food bank need is a basic rate of benefit support that falls woefully short of the cost of essentials. Losing your job, needing to care for a sick family member or breaking up with your partner can happen to any of us. Universal Credit should offer support to anyone who falls on hard times, but the basic rate will be just £98 a week from April. This is well below the £120 a week that the Joseph Rowntree Foundation [JRF] estimates people need, at a minimum, to afford essentials.
The basic rate of support has fallen by 9 per cent in real terms since 2010. But a key structural flaw is that benefit levels have never been set according to any logical calculation, such as the cost of food and bills. Today’s rates are simply the result of years of changes, shaped by the rate the year before, inflation, welfare cuts and political considerations. This has allowed the shortfall to persist, forcing people to skip meals and turn off heating to get by, with five in six low-income families on Universal Credit going without essentials.
The number of children in poverty in the UK rose to a record high just before the 2024 general election, reaching 4.5 million in the latest official statistics. That is the stark situation laid bare in the JRF’s recent UK Poverty report.
Poverty affects children disproportionately because families face extra costs and childcare responsibilities that limit good work opportunities. Children in single parent families are at particular risk, with 43 per cent below the poverty line, compared to 21 per cent of people on average. Younger children are harder hit too, with a child poverty rate of 36 per cent in families where the youngest child is under 5.
Poverty has also deepened over recent decades. In the latest data, almost half of people in poverty were in very deep poverty, having an income of less than 40 per cent of the UK median income, far below the poverty line which sits at 60 per cent. This compares to around a third in the mid-1990s.
This intensification of poverty is reflected in rising destitution – the most severe form of material hardship, where people cannot afford to stay warm, dry, clean and fed. Around 3.8 million people, including a million children, experienced destitution in 2022. This has more than doubled since 2017. Trussell provided 2.9 million emergency food parcels in the year ending March 2025, up by over 50 per cent from five years earlier.
Universal Credit should offer support to anyone who falls on hard times, we can’t allow the continued erosion of support. The urgency is clear. MPs must now advocate for change – benefits with minimum rates that reflect the true cost of essentials.■
About the author: Iain Porter is a senior policy advisor at the Joseph Rowntree Foundation.
👫Is this an issue you care about? Share this article with your friends, family and colleagues to help us reach more people with our independent journalism, always with a focus on people, policy and place.
Also in The Lead this week…
National Editor Natalie Morris spoke at the National Energy Action annual conference on Tuesday, highlighting our work at The Lead to expose the crisis within a crisis on child poverty. Have a read of her key takeaways from the powerful event.
Child poverty is racialised – we won't end the crisis until this is acknowledged
Arriving in Newcastle for the National Energy Action Conference, February’s cold cut through coats and scarves, with icy rain driven sideways by the wind. It was the kind of cold that embeds itself in your bones. A fitting reminder that for millions of families across the UK, discomfort like this isn’t just a fleeting encounter with the elements – it’s …
The political drama has been high for the past fortnight, and remains so, and our Westminster Editor Zoë Grünewald saw first-hand at the Resolution Foundation’s launch of Unsung Britain this week - where all the questions were almost exclusively about Keir Starmer while the issue of declining living standards, lack of wage growth and prospects was ignored.
Unsung Britain: a wake up call over sliding living standards buried under Westminster drama
On Tuesday, I attended the launch of the Resolution Foundation’s Unsung Britain report, a real wake-up call for anyone serious about the UK’s deeper economic malaise.
Endorsements from a Nazi propagandist, and a police investigation in Gorton and Denton – we’re keeping tabs on all things Reform UK so you don’t have to.
Reform Watch: Neo-Nazi AI slop, defunding Bangor and more on Matt Goodwin
The Lead is keeping an eye on Reform UK and their fellow travellers. Get in touch on X, Bluesky and Instagram or email ella@thelead.uk with tips and stories. We especially want to hear from readers whose local council is now run by Farage’s followers.
The latest from our award-winning team at The Lead North, from an innovative blueprint for tackling flooding, to the Blackpool councillors going into hiding.
Notes from the North: Saved from climate change by the local authority, councillors fear physical attacks and threats
When water rose to the ceilings of the first floor of homes in Clydach Terrace, in Ynysybwl, it marked the start of a nightmare for people living there.
After some further reading?
Natalie recommends Nadine White's insightful reporting in Black Current News on the insidious racism that is repeatedly present in the Epstein files. It has been largely overlooked how race frequently played an explicit role in how girls were selected by men.
Ed recommends this new Substack from Enda Leahy, who created the Courtsdesk, an open justice system that has been eradicated due to poor government data. He’s making his case for why the tool – which is extremely useful, particularly for local journalists – should not be scrapped.
And Zoë hosted an episode of Oh God What Now with Ian Hughes, author of Disordered Minds : How Dangerous Personalities Are Destroying Democracy, where they discussed why it feels like the world is increasingly being run by psychopaths. It made her think about this wonderful African proverb: “The child who does not feel love will burn down the village to feel its warmth.”
Here at The Lead we’re campaigning to end child poverty. Scrapping the two-child benefit cap is a welcome and overdue move, but now we’re looking ahead to what comes next. As Iain has set out above, a minimum floor for Universal Credit would have a tangible impact on those most in need. This weekend, former editor of The Big Issue North and our reporter, Kevin Gopal, speaks to the families at the sharp end of the crisis, to find out just how much of a difference a policy like this would make. Make sure you’re subscribed to receive it first.
This is so informative! Thanks for publishing. We also appreciate the shout-out to Black Current News 🥰